Economic Substance ("Substance") is one of the main conditions for a company to operate in a foreign jurisdiction where its business has been registered. Conducting real business activity and properly documenting economic presence help a company meet the legal requirements of the relevant jurisdiction and reduce the risk of claims from tax authorities and regulators. The experts of the international law firm Maira Consult will help you understand what "substance" is and why it matters for consulting companies.
Substance confirms that a company has a proper economic presence in the relevant jurisdiction and carries out activities there in accordance with local law.
For firms that provide financial, management, marketing, legal, or HR consulting services, complying with substance requirements is extremely important. This line of business attracts close attention from supervisory authorities. The reason is the absence of warehouses, production sites, and retail outlets. That is why tax authorities may pay particular attention to payments for intangible services, checking their economic justification, the actual provision of the services, and their compliance with the terms of the transactions.
Authorities that require substance
Several key bodies at once impose real economic presence requirements on a consulting company:
The tax authority in the country where the business is registered. Tax authorities determine the right to use a double tax treaty and the tax incentives in force.
The tax authority of the parent company's jurisdiction. Where controlled foreign companies exist, the tax authority decides whether to include the profit of the foreign subsidiary in the tax base of the resident parent company.
Payment systems and banks. A company's real presence allows payment institutions to rule out illegal capital transit.
Tax auditors in the countries from which payments originate. Proof of substance affects the possibility of applying reduced withholding tax rates.
Oversight of compliance with economic presence requirements is multi-layered. All financial regulators act in coordination and exchange information automatically. It is extremely important to arrange legal support from Maira Consult for confirming Economic Substance already at the stage of setting up the business.
Substance criteria

To confirm economic presence, a company must meet the requirements set by the legislation of the relevant jurisdiction. Depending on the type of activity and the applicable regime, they may include the following criteria:
Basic criteria | Details |
Office premises | A physical office is confirmed by a signed lease agreement, a local phone number, utility payments, an equipped workspace, a name sign, and a place to store accounting and financial records. |
Employed staff | The evidence provided includes employment contracts with qualified employees and a local director, as well as documents showing salary payments to them. |
Board meetings in the country of registration | All board meetings, as well as the minutes recording management decisions, must be held and signed in the jurisdiction of the company's tax residency. |
Administrative expenses | With genuine economic presence, a firm should incur expenses for local accountants, office equipment, office maintenance, telephony, filing of reports, and local hosting services. |
Depending on the jurisdiction, the lack of evidence of real economic activity in the country where a consulting company is registered leads to fines and a number of other problems. In the British Virgin Islands, for the first established breach of Economic Substance requirements by an ordinary legal entity, the penalty is a fine of USD 5,000 to 20,000, and for a repeat breach, USD 10,000 to 200,000. Imprisonment for up to 5 years may be applied for certain offenses, in particular failure to provide requested information or providing false information. In the UAE, the Economic Substance Regulations applied to financial periods ending no later than 31 December 2022. At the same time, to benefit from the preferential Qualifying Free Zone Person regime under corporate tax rules, a company must meet separate economic presence requirements.
In EU countries and Cyprus, the lack of proper economic presence may make it harder to confirm a company's tax residency and to apply the benefits of double tax treaties.
"In practice, we recommend assessing Economic Substance requirements before the company is registered, rather than when a bank or tax authority has already asked for proof of its real activity. It is important to understand that there is no universal set of substance requirements: the necessary measures depend on the jurisdiction, the type of activity, the structure of the business, and the functions the company actually performs. That is why the economic presence model should be built for the specific situation, so that it complies with the law and can be properly supported by documents," says Iryna Kucheriava, Managing Partner of Maira Consult.
Substance compliance and successful banking

In most banks and payment systems in the EU, the UK, and the US, substance standards are treated as one of the compliance criteria. KYC/AML assessment also includes checking the business for signs of a shell company. If there is no evidence of economic presence, consulting companies may face the following sanctions:
refusal to open a corporate account at the company registration stage;
suspension of client servicing until a full package of documents is received confirming a physical office, staff on payroll, and real activity in the country;
blocking of transactions until documents are submitted for each deal;
a ban on cross-border transfers;
forced closure of the corporate account with unilateral termination of the agreement by the bank;
blacklisting, with no possibility of arranging servicing in the future at any subsidiary branches of the financial group in different countries.
If a bank decides that a consulting firm lacks substance, the data may be sent to the financial intelligence unit and the financial monitoring authority. The information is also transmitted through the CRS/DAC tax information exchange system to the place of residence of all beneficiaries. In that case, there is a high risk of reclassification of tax status and additional tax assessments. Maira Consult specialists provide legal services on substance to consulting companies for successful registration, opening a bank account, and its smooth servicing in the future.
Advantages of substance for tax planning
One of the key advantages of meeting substance requirements is that the consulting company obtains a tax residency certificate. This allows it to legally use tax optimization tools.
Reducing Withholding Tax
Withholding Tax can be reduced or abolished entirely. When the client pays the fee, no tax is withheld at source under the double tax treaty, which allows the consulting company to receive 100% of the profit.
Protection against Permanent Establishment
When a firm's specialists provide consulting services in another country over a long period, the tax authority of that jurisdiction may recognize a permanent establishment. This would result in taxation of all profit in the country where the project is actually carried out. With a tax residency certificate, the tax jurisdiction is clearly determined and the taxation system is delineated.
Preferential repatriation tax rate
In a cross-border settlement for consulting services provided, WHT may be charged to non-residents. The company's status as a tax resident allows the tax counterparty to withhold royalties or withholding tax at a reduced rate.
Compliance with substance requirements is also important for a consulting firm's business reputation. Confirmed substance builds trust both with partners and with the banking system. In practice, there are no claims from the tax inspectorate or local regulators.
Substance is aimed at preventing tax evasion and the creation of paper-only companies, and at encouraging companies to carry out real business activity in the country of registration. Maira Consult lawyers will not only advise on what "substance" is and why it matters for consulting companies. The specialists will help organize the staffing aspects of the firm's operations, rent an office, hold meetings in the jurisdiction, resolve communication with government authorities, and prepare financial statements.





